An assessment of parliamentarian roles on security sector. All actors influencing the quality of democratic governance of the security sector security sector plus nonstate security organisations. In this context, a special focus is placed on improving governance through greater civilian and parliamentary oversight of security processes. The parliamentary dimension of security sector reform jstor. In the reconstruction and transformation of any post war country, security sector reform ssr is key.
Caroline gardner, the auditor general for scotland, said. Security sector governance and oversight stimson center. Nov 28, 2018 the negative trends in ugandas parliamentary practice are mainly due to a decline in the willingness of lawmakers to exercise oversight and assert their independence as a result of a sharp increase in patronage stemming from efforts by the government to hold onto office. Indeed, through its institutions and field operations, the organization has for quite some time been providing expertise to participating states on. A survey of 25 european parliaments sandra dieterich, hartwig hummel and stefan marschall. Dcaf provides in country advisory support and practical assistance programmes, develops and promotes appropriate democratic norms at the international and national levels, advocates good practices and makes policy recommendations to ensure effective democratic governance of the security sector. For the purpose of this backgrounder, the security sector consists of all organised groups in society that are capable of using force, as. The place of parliament in different political systems. Roles and responsibilities in good security sector. Parliamentary involvement in security policy and security sector reform also ensures that citizens. Apart from the major universal principles, each coun. Training resources on parliamentary oversight of the. The aim of good governance in the public sector international framework is to encourage better service delivery and improved accountability by establishing a benchmark for good governance in the public sector.
The international framework is not intended to replace national and sectoral governance codes. What groups and institutions play a role in the security sector. Tool7 genderandssrtoolkit parliamentary oversight of the. All three states carry out security sector reform in line with the firm advice and demands of. This paper focuses only on the parliamentarian roles in oversight of security governance sector in cambodia and finally presents some recommendation to promote the parliamentary roles in oversight defense and security sector. What factors have driven the emergence and evolution of ssr. This tool on parliamentary oversight of the security sector and gender is part of a genderandssrtoolkit. The role of parliament in promoting good governance. Section ii describes all stages of the national security policy cycle as well the international regulations which are.
Geneva centre for the democratic control of armed forces. All the institutions of state responsible for securing the state and its. Defence and security sector reform and parliamentary. Consequently, the western balkan countries albania, bosnia and herzegovina bih, kosovo, the former yugoslav republic of macedonia fyr macedonia, montenegro and serbia have begun security sector reforms as part of their euro. Pdf this case study seeks to assess the contribution of ghanas. Dcaf provides incountry advisory support and practical assistance programmes, develops and promotes appropriate democratic norms at the international and national levels, advocates good practices and makes policy recommendations to ensure effective democratic governance of the security sector. Good governance in the public sector consultation draft.
It has been widely recognised that if security institutions are not fully under democratic civilian control, they can impede the development of the state in a. This handbook offers a comprehensive set of practices and mechanisms which might shape parliaments contribution to security oversight. Good governance of the security sector in southeast asia. He cited parliamentary capacitybuilding as one of the. Parliamentary oversight of the security sector lessons from ghana which focused on a. The security sector reform monitor is a quarterly publication that tracks developments and trends in the ongoing security sector reform ssr processes of five countries. The concepts of security sector governance and reform ssgr, or ssg and ssr generally refer to a process in westernbased international development and democratization to amend the security sector of a state towards good governance and its principles, such as freedom of information and the rule of law the objective of security sector reform ssr is to achieve good security sector. It focused on the role of parliaments in the good governance of the security sector in southeast asia. The united states is the most visible example of presidential system, but presidentialism is predominant in latin. European parliament ex ante powers in oversight of esdp 11 4. Parliamentaryoversightforthesecuritysectoranditsreform. In the notes for a speech to the 84th roseroth seminar of the nato parliamentary assembly on afghanistan, regional security and the future of international cooperation, conducted in bishkek, kyrgyzstan, 15 november 20, the author outlines two reasons for failings of. Jan 25, 2017 parliamentary powers in security sector governance this publication contains two sections. The role of the parliament in the democratic control of.
The full list of contributors therefore also includes those who participated in the production of the ipudcaf handbook. Central asia, civil society, defence reform, integrity, oversight, security sector reform abstract. Factors affecting the extent of parliamentary power include. The 10th anniversary workshop of the inter parliamentary forum on security sector governance in southeast asia ipfssg took place in siem reap, cambodia, on 1516 september 2016.
Geneva centre for the democratic control of armed forces dcaf occasional paper 21 parliamentary war powers. First, an introductory text on parliamentary oversight with the aim to help parliamentarians and nonparliamentarians alike to understand what the powers of an ambitious, competent and wellprepared parliament and its committees can be and what good they can do. Security sector reform, and security sector governance in particular, are critical to protect human rights, and reassert civilian control over a states a. Handbook for parliamentarians parliamentary oversight of. This act is the public sector governance act 2018 and comes 5 into operation on a date that the minister appoints by notification in the gazette. At the same time, the complex nature of security issues makes it impossible to treat all aspects in a single volume. Good governance in the public sector consultation draft for. The negative trends in ugandas parliamentary practice are mainly due to a decline in the willingness of lawmakers to exercise oversight and assert their independence as a result of a sharp increase in patronage stemming from efforts by the government to hold onto office. Handbook for parliamentarians parliamentary oversight of the. In this capacity, he worked on parliamentary outreach programmes in eastern europe, southeast asia, middle east and western africa. More broadly, parliamentary oversight is a critical component of legislative governance of the security sector. Obstacles to security sector reform in new democracies berghof. An effective, accountable, security sector, respectful of the rule of law. Pdf parliamentary oversight of the security sector.
Public sector governance bill parliament house, singapore. The mandate and powers of these parliamentary oversight bodies varies considerably. Since the 1990s, western balkan countries have all, in the push to reform their security sectors, made significant progress in terms of setting up the necessary legal framework and oversight mechanisms. Political, holistic, integral part of a process of a democratization process, transparency, inclusivity, security sector governance ssg a redefinition of security.
Updating key information on best practices related to parliamentary oversight and guidance of the security sector, the volume retains a special focus on defence affairs and puts the oversight role of. Although security sector governance and reform ssgr is a relatively new concept, it goes hand in hand with the osces comprehensive understanding of security. All the institutions of state responsible for securing the state and its population from fear of violence. A consequence of governance failures in soes is the impact this has on the private sectors ability to perform and contribute to. Every quarter, there will be separate editions for each case study country. The concepts of security sector governance and reform ssgr, or ssg and ssr generally refer to a process in westernbased international development and democratization to amend the security sector of a state towards good governance and its principles, such as freedom of information and the rule of law. For examples of piocs in four countries, see table on page 5. Governance has a fundamental role in security sector reform. Afghanistan, burundi, haiti, timorleste and southern sudan.
Why does a country need a wellgoverned and effi cient security sector. Governing the use of force under international auspices. Parliamentary oversight of the security sector the web site cannot. Reducing the size, budget and scope of activity of the security sector and reforming it.
Much of eastern europe has adopted this model since the early 1990s. Parliamentarianism may also be heeded for governance in local governments. Political, holistic, integral part of a process of a democratization process, transparency, inclusivity, security sector governance ssg a. Parliamentary accountability for the use of force under international auspices is a good case in point for illuminating the internal or. The powers, procedures and practices of parliamentary. Parliamentary powers in security sector governance this publication contains two sections. The government has done well to date but has had to work flat out to reach this point, leaving little time to draw breath and plan for the challenges ahead. Usaid programming in security sector reform has included programs focused on civilsecurity force relations, policing, civilian oversight of the military, parliamentary reform, public administration, policy making, access to justice, judicial reform, transitional justice and ddr. It has been written on the assumption that there is no single model of parliamentary oversight which works for all countries. Duncan hiscock the role of civil society in security. Usaid programming in security sector reform has included programs focused on civil security force relations, policing, civilian oversight of the military, parliamentary reform, public administration, policy making, access to justice, judicial reform, transitional justice and ddr. What are the main principles of democratic governance of the security sector. Professor boubacar ndiaye introduced the african security sector network.
He emphasized that there could be no talk of democracy without an active parliament and that security must be regarded as a public good and not as the preserve of the executive. Parliamentary powers in security sector governance ukraine. This third version of the dcafnato pa vademecum underlines the essential role that parliaments must play in ensuring democratic oversight of the security sector. The 10th anniversary workshop of the interparliamentary forum on security sector governance in southeast asia ipfssg took place in siem reap, cambodia, on 1516 september 2016.
The handbook should therefore be seen as a broad introduction to enhancing parliamentary oversight of the security sector which it is hoped will encourage the reader to carry out further research. In summary, we are opining that tension and sometimes conflict are still prevalent in the interaction between the security sector and the civil authority. Addressing international governance challenges security. First, an introductory text on parliamentary oversight with the aim to help parliamentarians and nonparliamentarians alike to understand what the powers of an ambitious, competent and wellprepared parliament and its committees can be and what good they. Parliamentary oversight of the security sector interparliamentary. It has been widely recognised that if security institutions are not fully under democratic civilian control, they can impede the development of the state in a number of ways. Secondly, the publication contains a a selfassessmenta kit that helps parliamentary and nonparliamentary security and governance experts understand where their parliament stands and what further improvements could be made in the light of a best practicesa. Parliamentary powers in security sector governance dcaf.
Parliamentary powers in security sector governance. Genderresponsive parliamentary oversight of the security sector seeks to. Security sector reform became a current concept only after. Parliamentary oversight of the security sector refers to the role the democraticallyelected branch of the legislature plays in oversight and monitoring of security sector policies and practices. Parliamentary committees in new democracies also typically lack expertise on security. In general, efforts to improve governance in soes have lagged behind the private sector, both in south africa and elsewhere8, despite the enabling regulatory framework in place. An example is the city of oslo, which has an executive council as a part of the parliamentary system. Armed forces, security sector, parliamentary oversight. What is meant by security sector governance and security sector reform. Parliaments have a vital role to play in the good governance of the security sector and the provision of transparent and accountable public security.
The role of the parliament in the democratic control of the. Security sector governance and reform what groups and institutions play a role in the security sector. Both the european union and nato have sought to promote democratic security sector governance as one of the criteria for their respective accession candidates. The rules and practices that are accepted and effective in one place may be unthinkable or irrelevant in another. In addition, the reforms involve balancing the resources. This document is part of the dcaf backgrounder series, which provides practitioners with concise introductions to a variety of issues in the field of security sector governance and reform. Principles, mechanisms, and practices parliaments have a vital role to play in the good governance of the security sector and the provision of transparent and accountable public security. Duncan hiscock the role of civil society in security sector. With an understanding of local power structures and dynamics, and where actors sit. Ghana poses a genuine case of deepening democratic control over the security. Designed to provide a practical introduction to gender issues for security sector reform practitioners and policymakers, the toolkit includes the following 12 tools and.
1135 106 135 145 945 641 329 608 426 1559 296 960 233 1260 1468 360 787 1066 74 1258 885 1560 792 27 1274 682 63 912 398